Central Michigan University: Assessment of Security Fees for Controversial Speaker

In a victory for freedom of expression and freedom of association, Central Michigan University (CMU) agreed to provide security for a speech by author and conservative activist David Horowitz hosted by Campus Conservatives, the Young Americans for Freedom chapter at CMU. CMU had initially refused to provide security without imposing an excessive financial burden on the club. FIRE wrote CMU President Michael Rao, urging CMU to meet its constitutional obligation not to financially burden speech that others might find offensive. FIRE's letter pointed out that the Supreme Court has declared such burdens unconstitutional.

    Blog Entries

  • "With Horowitz Speech Scheduled, Central Michigan Struggles with Free Speech Issues," by Adam Kissel, October 14, 2008: In a victory for freedom of expression and freedom of association, Central Michigan University (CMU) has agreed to provide security for a speech tonight by author and conservative activist David Horowitz. The speech will be hosted by Campus Conservatives, the Young Americans for Freedom chapter at CMU. FIRE wrote CMU President Michael Rao on October 10, urging CMU to meet its constitutional obligation not to financially burden speech that others might find offensive. FIRE's letter pointed out that the Supreme Court has declared such burdens unconstitutional. In a response yesterday, Rao promised to provide two requested officers for the event, but said that CMU would review its historical security practices prior to a final determination about responsibility for security costs. Rao's response is both constitutionally and morally troubling, as it suggests that the angriest and most violent protesters might enjoy a "heckler's veto" by threatening violence, leaving speakers and hosts to foot the bill for security or else cancel events.