E-mail from YAF President Dennis Lennox II to Director of Student Life Thomas Idema, Jr., February 20, 2007
February 20, 2007
From: Dennis-George Lennox II [E-mail address redacted]
Sent: Tuesday, February 20, 2007 11:16 AM
To: Idema Jr, Thomas H
Subject: Question - Urgent
Hi Tom -
Our organization has a serious situation.
There are a few students on campus that belong to the
Gay-Straight Alliance and a couple other liberal/left-wing
RSOs who have been trying to join our organization, a
conservative group, with the sole purpose of disrupting our
meetings and possibly joining to impeach us, take over Young
Americans for Freedom and dissolve the CMU chapter. (They have
said just as much on a Facebook group that targets us
YAF has membership dues and other requirements for joining,
but we don't know how far we can go in preventing someone who
does not agree with our purpose from joining and ruining the
How far can we go in restricting membership without violating
the non-discrimination clause?
Our lawyer has advised us the Supreme Court has upheld our
rights and the rights of other private organizations to
determine membership eligibility, and we cannot be forced to
accept someone who disagrees with us or our stated purpose -
just as a Christian group, which can't be required to accept a
Muslim or a homosexual.
Could you please clarify the university's policy? We have a
meeting this evening at 8 p.m.
Dennis Lennox II