University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill: Heckler's Veto Results in Termination of Emeritus Professor's Network Access
The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (UNC) succumbed to the "heckler's veto" by revoking Emeritus Professor Elliot Cramer's network access because of outside complaints about a website link to an organization that advocates for animal welfare. Despite telling the complainant that the dispute was "not a University matter" and that the university did not monitor website content, UNC nevertheless demanded that Cramer remove the link from his website and later canceled his network access. FIRE wrote UNC in protest, and General Counsel Leslie Chambers Strohm replied stating that UNC would not restore Cramer's network access, redefining Cramer's reasonable, good-faith efforts to defend himself as part of the problem/ Strohm also claimed that UNC had not acted due to the content of Cramer's expression, despite the fact that Strohm herself had ordered Cramer to remove content from his website.
- "UNC-Chapel Hill Surrenders to 'Heckler's Veto,' Revokes Emeritus Professor's Network Access," June 21, 2011: The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (UNC) has surrendered to the "heckler's veto" by revoking Professor Emeritus Elliot Cramer's network access following outside complaints about a link on his website to an organization that advocates for animal welfare. Despite telling the complaining individual that the dispute was "not a University matter" and that the university did not monitor the content of websites maintained by professors, UNC nevertheless demanded that Cramer remove the link from his website and later canceled his network access entirely. Cramer came to FIRE for help.
- "Response from UNC General Counsel Strohm to FIRE, June 15, 2011," June 15, 2011
- "FIRE letter to UNC Chapel Hill Chancellor Holden Thorp, June 1, 2011," June 1, 2011
- "Email from UNC General Counsel Leslie Chambers Strohm to Joseph Villarosa, April 20, 2011," April 20, 2011
- "Email from UNC General Counsel Leslie Chambers Strohm to Eliot Cramer, April 20, 2011," April 20, 2011
Case Materials
- "Will Threat of Legal Action Spur UNC to Restore Emeritus Professor's Rights?," by Peter Bonilla, September 20, 2011
- "'Chronicle' Article on Emeritus Faculty Highlights Case of Wronged UNC Professor," by Peter Bonilla, August 15, 2011
- "'Triangle Business Journal' on UNC's Revocation of Emeritus Professor's Network Access," by Peter Bonilla, July 1, 2011
- "FIRE's Shibley Raps UNC's Punishment of Emeritus Professor in 'Herald-Sun'," by Peter Bonilla, June 24, 2011
- "FIRE Corrects the Record on 'Inside Higher Ed' Reporting of UNC Case," by Peter Bonilla, June 22, 2011
- "UNC-Chapel Hill Surrenders to 'Heckler's Veto,' Revokes Emeritus Professor's Network Access," by Peter Bonilla, June 21, 2011
Blog Entries
- "Annoy UNC to silence its profs,"
by Robert Shibley, The Herald-Sun, June 23, 2011 - "Borrowed Gravitas,"
by Steve Kolowich, Inside Higher Ed, June 22, 2011


