University of California, Santa Barbara: Viewpoint Discrimination in Student Activity Funding
UCSB's student government, the Associated Students, repeatedly engaged in unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination against the College Republicans by denying funding for a speech by conservative author David Horowitz due to Horowitz's expression and viewpoints. After the Associated Students Finance Board (ASFB) voted that the group should receive no funding, the group appealed to the Associated Students Legislative Council (ASLC). According to the minutes of both meetings, student government members gave many unconstitutional reasons for not funding the event, citing Horowitz's views, past expression, and possible future expression. The ASLC also voted to remove the record of the ASFB's earlier discussion from public view, and student government leaders apparently lied to UCSB officials about the situation after FIRE intervened. UCSB officials provided conflicting information to FIRE and the College Republicans for months before finally producing documentation demonstrating that it had provided most of the funding that the ASFB had denied.
- "Victory at UC Santa Barbara: University Nixes Student Government's Unconstitutional Rejection of David Horowitz Speech," October 10, 2011: Officials at the University of California, Santa Barbara (UCSB) have stepped in after its student government unconstitutionally denied funding for a speech by conservative activist David Horowitz. The student government had engaged in unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination on two separate occasions and then tried to hide the evidence of its wrongdoing. The College Republicans, Horowitz's hosts, came to FIRE for help.
- "Letter to FIRE from Campus Counsel Nancy Hamill, June 21, 2011," June 21, 2011
- "UCSB College Republicans Fund Audit Report, Updated June 7, 2011," June 7, 2011
- "FIRE Second Letter to UC Santa Barbara Chancellor Henry T. Yang, June 7, 2011," June 7, 2011
- "Allocation information from UCSB Special Projects Coordinator Barbra Ortiz, May 26, 2011," May 26, 2011
- "Jewish And Muslim Students Unite To Debunk Horowitz’s Claims," Daily Nexus, May 26, 2011
- "UCSB Hosts Horowitz," Daily Nexus, May 26, 2011
- "UCSB Campus Counsel Nancy Greenan Hamill Letter to FIRE, May 20, 2011," May 20, 2011
- "FIRE Letter to University of California, Santa Barbara, Chancellor Henry T. Yang, May 6, 2011," May 6, 2011
- "Council Meets Controversy," Daily Nexus, May 5, 2011
- "Associated Students Legislative Council Meeting Minutes, May 4, 2011," May 4, 2011
- "Email from Associated Student Finance Board Member Lucy Nguyen to College Republicans, May 3, 2011," May 3, 2011
- "Board Denies Funding for David Horowitz Event," Daily Nexus, May 3, 2011
- "University of California, Santa Barbara, Associated Students Finance Board Meeting Notes (Excerpts), May 2, 2011," May 2, 2011
Case Materials
- "UCSB's 'Daily Nexus' Struggles to Accept the Truth after Viewpoint Discrimination against David Horowitz Event," by Adam Kissel, October 28, 2011
- "'San Francisco Chronicle' Reprints UCSB's Lies about Viewpoint Discrimination against David Horowitz Event," by Adam Kissel, October 26, 2011
- "Victory at UC Santa Barbara: University Nixes Student Government's Unconstitutional Rejection of David Horowitz Speech," by Adam Kissel, October 10, 2011
- "FIRE to UC Santa Barbara: Stop Student Government's Viewpoint Discrimination," by Adam Kissel, June 8, 2011
- "Students Peacefully Engage Horowitz at UCSB, but Student Government Injustices Remain Uncorrected," by Peter Bonilla, May 31, 2011
- "Much More Evidence of Viewpoint Discrimination by UC Santa Barbara Student Government Regarding Tonight's David Horowitz Event (Details)," by Adam Kissel, May 26, 2011
- "Much More Evidence of Viewpoint Discrimination by UC Santa Barbara Student Government Regarding Tonight's David Horowitz Event," by Adam Kissel, May 26, 2011
- "UC Santa Barbara Student Government Tries to Derail David Horowitz Event, Lies About It," by Adam Kissel, May 26, 2011: The University of California, Santa Barbara (UCSB) student government has unconstitutionally discriminated against the UCSB College Republicans by twice denying funding for a lecture tonight by David Horowitz because of his conservative views. After FIRE pointed out that discriminating on the basis of political views in student fee funding violates the First Amendment, UCSB student leaders apparently lied to UCSB officials, stating that Horowitz's views were not a factor in the denial of funding. Meeting minutes and news articles prove, however, that UCSB unlawfully discriminated on the basis of viewpoint. Horowitz nevertheless will speak at UCSB tonight.
Blog Entries
- "Leftist Censors Defeated at UC Santa Barbara,"
by Arnold Ahlert, FrontPage Magazine, October 21, 2011 - "Free speech: UCSB reimburses College Republicans,"
by Bob Egelko, San Francisco Chronicle, October 13, 2011 - "Free Speech Victory at UC Santa Barbara,"
FrontPage Magazine, October 13, 2011 - "Speaker David Horowitz Causes Controversy... UCSB Students Fear "Islamophobia","
by David Horowitz, FrontPage Magazine, May 26, 2011 - "Suppressing Speech at UC Santa Barbara,"
by Nichole Hungerford, FrontPage Magazine, May 18, 2011


